6 Blue Buffalo Cat Food Reviews and Recalls (2019 Update)

Blue buffalo cat food reviews

Blue Buffalo cat food has carved a niche in the pet foods industry as the leader in premium quality, all natural pet nutrition.

A brand that started with a single dog recipe now has dozens of dog and cat food brands that have become popular among pet parents.

The company currently has four lines of pet food products on the market. 

The products include the Wilderness line of all-natural pet foods, Freedom line of grain-free recipes, the Basics line of limited ingredient diets and lastly and the Blue line of all natural pet foods.

Blue Buffalo Cat Food Reviews Comparison Chart

Blue Buffalo Formula


Where to Buy

Blue Wilderness High Protein Wet Cat Food

Blue Wilderness High Protein Dry Cat Food (Best Seller)

Blue Healthy Gourmet Wet Cat Food

What is the History of Blue Buffalo Pet Foods?

Blue Buffalo was founded in 2002 by Bill Bishop, and it continues to operate as a family business.

The company is headquartered in Wilton, Connecticut. It is owned by the Bishop Family, even though the founders say that “Old Blue” is the founder.

Blue was the family’s favorite dog who died of cancer at the onset of the business. The dog’s death inspired Bill to create a natural pet diet using high-quality ingredients that are safe and healthy for pets.

Blue Buffalo has employed 1500 plus food specialists, nutritionists, and veterinarians, to prepare the Buffalo pet foods in its US kitchens.

The company assures that all its Blue Buffalo Basics line of products are 100% manufactured in the United States and are grain-free. It operates as a subsidiary of the Blue Pets LLC.

Are Blue Buffalo cat foods good for my cat?

Blue Buffalo is one the most popular brands of premium cat foods that produce healthy meals for our fur babies.

However, the company has recalled some of its pets foods in the past, i.e., 2007, 2010, and 2015 for possible food contamination. We have covered these recalls in this article.

Despite these recalls, the company has moved to restore its customer’s confidence through improved food preparation process that is overseen by Ph.D. food specialists.

Blue Buffalo cat foods are some of the most popular cat foods for the following reasons:

  • They are moderately affordable.
  • Their recipes are prepared with real animal meat (Chicken, Salmon, Turkey, etc.)
  • High-protein cat foods.
  • Optimally balanced with fruits, vegetables, and vitamins for healthy cats.
  • Has a limited ingredient line of products to cater for cats with sensitive stomachs and weight management.

6 Best Blue Buffalo Cat Food Reviews

1. BLUE Wilderness High Protein Grain Free (Best Seller) 

Blue Buffalo Cat Food Reviews

Blue Wilderness is a high protein dry cat food that is prepared with deboned chicken as the first ingredient.

It does not contain poultry by-products like chicken hearts and liver. This formula comes in a 12lb bag that is adequate to last you several weeks.

Blue Wilderness Adult dry cat food is grain and gluten-free, and it is ideal for cats with allergies and sensitive stomach. It contains cranberries, blueberries, and carrots that inhibit oxidation of other components in the body.

This formula contains LifeSource Bits that are exclusive to Blue Buffalo diets. LifeSource Bits is a unique blend of essential vitamins and minerals that help support a healthy immune system and digestive health.

Top Ingredients: Deboned chicken, chicken meal, turkey meal, potato starch, fish meal (Omega 3 fatty acids), chicken fat, peas, flaxseed, vitamins, and minerals.

Guaranteed Analysis: Crude Proteins 40% (min), Crude fat 18% (min), Crude fiber 4% (max), Moisture 10% (max), Magnesium 0.08% (min) and Taurine 0.15% (min).

Calorific content: 3825 Kcals/kg; 435 kcals/cup

2. BLUE for Cats Adult Dry Cat Food 

Blue of cats adult dry cat food

Blue for cats adult dry cat food with deboned chicken as the first ingredient for cats that enjoy a meal of tasty chicken. It comes in a large 15-pound bag.

This formula also contains garden-grown veggies like cranberries, parsley, and carrots.

These ingredients are a rich source of phytonutrients that keep the cat healthy and strengthens the cat’s immune system to fight off common illnesses.

Like other Blue Buffalo dry cat foods, this diet contains LifeSource Bits which is a blend of essential vitamins and minerals.

Blue for cats adult dry cat food does NOT contain ant corn, wheat or soy which are known to cause allergies. There are no artificial preservatives or flavors.

Top Ingredients: Deboned chicken, chicken meal, turkey meal, brown rice, barley, chicken fat, peas, menhaden fish meal, oatmeal, potatoes, tomato pomace, flaxseed, vitamins, and minerals.

Guaranteed Analysis: Crude Proteins 32% (min), Crude fat 15% (min), Crude Fiber 6.0% (max), moisture 10% (max), Magnesium 0.08% (min) and Taurine 0.15%.

Calorie Content: 3634 Kcals/kg; 379 Kcals/cup.

3. BLUE Freedom Grain Free Adult Dry Cat Food 

Blue Buffalo Grain Free Adult Dry Cat Food

Looking for the best Blue Buffalo cat food for your indoor cat? The Blue Freedom Grain Free Adult Dry Cat Food is a premium dry kibble that is specially prepared for indoor cats.

It is prepared with the protein-rich deboned chicken to satisfy the cat’s urge for meat. It comes in an 11-pound bag.

It has well-balanced ingredients that help your cat maintain an ideal weight. This formula also contains healthy whole carrots, parsley, and cranberries that contain phytonutrients that strengthen the cat’s immune system, eyesight, and digestive health.

Blue Freedom Grain-free dry cat food contains fibers that help in digestion. The fibers also help in weight management by keeping the cat feeling full after eating low volumes of food.

This diet does NOT contain corn, wheat, soy, artificial preservatives or colors.

Top ingredients: Deboned chicken, chicken meal, peas, turkey meal, tapioca starch, turkey meal, chicken fat, pea protein, pea fiber, flaxseed (source of Omega 6 and Omega 3 fatty acids), dried egg, alfalfa meal, natural flavors, vitamins, and minerals.

Guaranteed Analysis: Crude Proteins 32% (min), Crude fat 14% (min), Crude fiber 7% (max), Moisture 10% (max), Taurine 0.15% (min) and Magnesium 0.08% (min).

Calorie Content: 3598 Kcals/kg; 375 Kcals/cup.

4. BLUE Wilderness High Protein Grain Free Wet Cat Food 

Blue Wilderness High Protein Grain Free Wet Cat Food

This formula is a chicken pet recipe that measures 12.5 oz. (also available in 3oz. and 5.5oz.).

It is prepared with natural ingredients such as chicken that are healthy and that your chicken will love. It is a perfect alternative if you are looking for near-raw diets. It is fortified with vitamins and minerals.

Apart from the chicken pate recipe, you can choose from other formulas like the duck pate recipe, salmon pate recipe, turkey pate recipe. This brand has both kitten food and adult cat formulas that you can buy.

This chicken pate recipe does not contain poultry by-products, corn, wheat, soy or artificial preservatives. The company also assures that this formula is 100% grain-free and does not contain glutens that most cat owners choose to avoid.

Top Ingredients: Chicken, chicken broth, chicken liver, potatoes, natural flavor, Guar gum, flaxseed (omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids), potassium chloride and taurine.

Guaranteed Analysis: Crude Protein 10% (min), Crude fat 9% (min), Crude Fiber 1.5% (max), Moisture 78% (max) and Taurine 0.1% (min).

Calorie Content: 3oz. 1,554 Kcals/kg; 132 Kcals/can 5.5oz. 1,554 Kcals/kg; 242 Kcals/can.

5. BLUE Healthy Gourmet Wet Cat Food 

Blue Buffalo Cat Food Reviews

This formula is an indoor chicken pate entrée that is specially made for indoor cats.

It is prepared with protein-rich chicken as the first ingredient and supplemented with healthy fruits and veggies that boost the cat’s immune system and help in digestion. It comes in 3.0oz., 5.5oz., and 12.5oz.

The Blue Healthy Gourmet Variety also comes in other recipes such as Indoor salmon entrée, ocean fish and tuna entrée and beef entrée. All these recipes do not contain corn, wheat, soy, artificial colors or preservatives.

Pet parents who have used this healthy gourmet canned cat food recommend it for finicky eaters due to its great taste!

Top Ingredients: Chicken, chicken broth, chicken liver, natural flavor, ground brown rice, guar gum, cellulose, carrots, sweet potatoes and flaxseed (source of Omega-3 and Omega-6 fatty acids)

Guaranteed Analysis: Crude proteins 10% (min), Crude Fat 6% (min), Crude Fiber 2% (max), Moisture 78% (max) and Taurine 0.1% (min).

Calorie Content: 1,280 Kcals/kg; 108 Kcals/3-oz. can; 199 Kcals/5.5-oz. can; 454 Kcals/12.5-oz. can.

6. BLUE Freedom Grain Free Wet Cat Food for Kittens 

This diet is an indoor chicken pate recipe that is specially prepared for indoor kittens.

It is prepared with chicken to provide kittens with a foundation of a protein-rich diet. It comes in 3.oz cans and in a pack of 24 to last you for several weeks or months.

This formula comprises the healthy cranberries fruits that are known to help in urinary health, by keeping the urinary tract functioning properly.

It also has a natural blend of natural dietary fibers that help in digestion, minimizing litter box odor and hairball control.

Blue Freedom grain-free, so it has no glutens that most pet parents are cautious about. Also, it does not contain poultry by-products, corn, wheat or soy.

Top Ingredients: Chicken, chicken liver, chicken broth, carrots, sweet potatoes, natural flavor, fish oil, flaxseed (source of Omega-3 and 6 fatty acids), guar gum, cellulose, taurine, cranberries, and blueberries.

Guaranteed Analysis: Crude protein 10% (min), Crude fat 7% (min), Crude fiber 1.5%, Moisture 78% (max) and Taurine 0.1% (min).

Calorie Content: 1370 Kcals/kg; 116 Kcals/can.

Blue Buffalo Cat Food Recalls

There have been a several Blue Buffalo cat food recalls in the past. Recently, there has been a widespread rumor that there has a blue buffalo lead recall in 2017.

However, this remains a rumor since these allegations have not been proved and this matter is the subject of a lawsuit filed in June 2017. The following are some of the recalls that have been in the public domain starting with the most recent:

March 2018: There was a lawsuit against Blue Buffalo by a single plaintiff, which called into question the safety of Blue Buffalo Dog and Cat foods.

The plaintiff claimed that levels of lead were found in three pet foods. However, the court dismissed the lawsuit since there was no evidence to support the allegations.

February 2017: Blue Buffalo announced a recall for potential metal contamination. Pet foods recalled include Blue Buffalo Homestyle Recipe Healthy Weight and Chicken Dinner with Garden Vegetables Dog Food.

March 2016: Blue Buffalo announced a recall due to potential mold contamination. Pet foods recalled include the 30-pound bags of Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Fish and Sweet Potato Recipe dog food.

November 2015: Blue Buffalo announced a recall for potential salmonella in the pet foods. Formulas recalled include 2.0z. bag of Blue Kitty Yums Tasty Chicken Recipe Cat Treats.

October 2010: Blue Buffalo issued a recall for potentially too much proportions of Vitamin D. Formulas recalled include Blue Wilderness Chicken Flavor dog food, Blue Basics L.I.D. formula salmon and potato recipe dog food and Blue life protection formula natural chicken and brown rice recipe dog food.

April 2007: Blue Buffalo announced a recall of its formulas for potential melamine contamination.

 Formulas recalled include all cans of Blue Buffalo Blue dog food, all cans of Blue Buffalo SPA select cat food, all pouches of Blue Buffalo dog treats and Blue Buffalo SPA select dry kitten food.


Jenny is an avid animal lover and enjoys spending time with her two adopted cats and one dog who lost one leg in an accident. Inspired to blog about pets by her dad, a retired veterinarian, and veteran.

View all posts


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • I purchased a bag of Blue Adult Indoor Health several days ago. I have fed my two cats this food since May 2018. I opened it yesterday to feed them and my one cat sniffed it and walked away. The other then did the same thing. I didn’t pay much attention but later in the day I noticed no one was eating dry food. I dumped it out this morning, washed their dish and refilled it. Again, they smelled it and walked away. I then smelled it and it has a sour smell to it. I went to the store this morning and purchased a new bag, fed them the new bag food and life is good. We are all happy. Is there a problem with Lot #20200129AH3 B 0617 Best by: 2020 JAN 29? Has anyone else complained? Sept. 13, 2018

  • Carol that is so strange. I noticed my big cat was losing weight. Finally realized both cats were sniffing the food and walking away too. I don’t have the bag but it is blue buffalo. I wonder what is going on.

  • My cats ate blue dry cat food for sensitive stomachs both are vomiting and my older cat can not walk hes dragging his hind legs and has blood in his urine its day three my younger cat won’t go near the food and I switched back to his usual hes starting to feel better but still isn’t eating much .

  • I recently purchased Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet chicken entree wet food for my cat. I had used half the can. When I went to warm up the other half in the microwave to feed my cat the food started sparking. This would lead me to believe that there is some type of metal in the product.

    • Did you contact the company? I have this food at home and my cat has been in and out of the hospital for the past two weeks. I stopped the food and he seems to be doing better.

      • I did contact them. They took all the lot information etc. but did not sound too concerned. I was told they would research it.

        • Thanks for the update, Cathy. Hoping you get a response soon. The best action, for now, would be to transition to another brand that your cat is used to, to prevent more health issues.